Veteran Composer Takes Stand Against AI in Creative Process
Nobuo Uematsu, the legendary composer behind the iconic Final Fantasy soundtrack, has publicly rejected the use of generative AI in music creation, stating he has never used the technology and “probably never will.” In a recent interview with JASRAC Magazine, Uematsu emphasized the intrinsic value of human creativity and the rewarding nature of overcoming artistic challenges through personal effort.
The Human Element in Musical Creation
Uematsu articulated a philosophy that prioritizes human experience over technological convenience. “I think it still feels more rewarding to go through the hardships of creating something myself,” he stated. The composer highlighted how listeners connect with music through understanding the creator’s background and personal journey – something AI fundamentally lacks.
He elaborated on the unique qualities of human-performed music: “Even when it comes to live performances, music produced by people is unstable, and everyone does it in their own unique way. And what makes it sound so satisfying are precisely those fluctuations and imperfections.” This perspective challenges the gaming industry’s increasing reliance on AI-generated content that prioritizes consistency over character.
Industry Context: Square Enix’s Aggressive AI Strategy
Uematsu’s stance creates an interesting contrast with his own publisher’s direction. Square Enix CEO Takashi Kiryu recently announced the company would be “aggressive in applying AI” and other cutting-edge technologies. This commitment was demonstrated when Foamstars producer Kosuke Okatani admitted the development team had “dabbled” with AI implementation.
The broader Japanese gaming industry appears to be following this trend. According to the Computer Entertainment Supplier’s Association (CESA), which organizes the Tokyo Game Show, over half of Japanese game companies are now using AI in their development processes. This widespread adoption reflects broader market trends toward automation and efficiency.
Technical Applications and Creative Concerns
While rejecting AI for core composition, Uematsu did acknowledge potential technical applications. When discussing advancements in game music, he suggested composers could work on smoothly transitioning between different pieces, noting that “Perhaps AI will be able to handle something like that well in the future.”
This nuanced view suggests a distinction between using AI for technical enhancements versus creative generation. As companies navigate these industry developments, Uematsu’s perspective offers a valuable counterpoint to the prevailing enthusiasm for automation.
Broader Industry Implications
The tension between Uematsu’s human-centric approach and the industry’s AI adoption reflects larger questions about creativity in the digital age. Recent technology infrastructure challenges have highlighted the limitations of automated systems, while ongoing economic considerations continue to drive efficiency-focused investments.
Uematsu has become increasingly vocal about musical direction in gaming, stating in a 2024 interview that game music has become too similar to film scores and “cannot develop further” if continuing in this direction. His commitment to returning for the Final Fantasy 7 Remake trilogy’s final theme song demonstrates his ongoing dedication to human-composed video game music.
As the industry continues to evolve, the debate between technological efficiency and artistic authenticity will likely intensify. Uematsu’s position serves as an important reminder of the value inherent in human creativity, even as companies explore new software and business strategies for the future.
Looking Forward
The gaming industry stands at a crossroads between technological advancement and artistic preservation. While AI offers undeniable benefits for development efficiency and technical implementation, Uematsu’s stance highlights the irreplaceable value of human experience in creative works. As developers balance these competing priorities, the industry’s approach to innovation and tradition will shape the future of gaming entertainment.
This article aggregates information from publicly available sources. All trademarks and copyrights belong to their respective owners.
Note: Featured image is for illustrative purposes only and does not represent any specific product, service, or entity mentioned in this article.
